Larry,
AISC 341-05 Seismic Provisions 8.2b table I-8-1 for rectangular HSS: b/t or h/tw is limited to .64*sqrt(E/Fy).
From: Larry Hauer [mailto:lhauer@live.com] 
 Sent: Friday, November 04, 2011 10:47 AM
 To: Struct. Eng. Assoc.
 Subject: Compact Tube Sections
To All,
  
 I guess I could research this myself, but probably getting lazy. I specified an HSS 5"x5"x1/4" stub column sticking out of the top of a concrete column to carry a light framed canopy load. The DSA plan check engineer, (California school), says that it is "not  seismically compact." Where do I find out what sections are and are not comact, (AISC 13th edition?)?
  
 Thanks in advance,
  
 Larry Hauer, S.E.